Referring to my earlier post:
Since the CIA in the '50s, '60s and '70s must have known about science, their actions in MK ULTRA are, if we give them the benefit of the doubt, puzzling. Why didn't they just rely solely on reputable scientists in relevant fields who were vetted, sworn to secrecy, and left to research the drugs in a manner they determined would be best and most efficient, with CIA approval and oversight?
When we think about it, there can only be a couple of explanations for the CIA's scuzzy conduct in MK ULTRA, and they are fairly straightforward:
(1) The CIA was disdainful of science, and was hesitant to consult scientists;
(2) The CIA agents wanted to go through a fantasy over and over again (maybe inspired by spy movies and TV shows) of picking people out, lowering their guard, surreptitiously slipping them a disabling drug like James Bond does, and then messing with them. Basically they were playing spy and picking on people. Certainly the motives of the shoddy, strange scientists the CIA did eventually pick out to help them seem about as bad.
Tuesday, July 15, 2008
A Final Word on MK ULTRA
Posted by
Swan
at
4:25 AM
|
Keep on rockin' in the free world
(This is something I wrote in a comment on something else, but I'm going to put it here as its own post because it's important to say on its own):
If you follow mainstream media and politics (like, for example, if you read the Media Matters website) then you'll be familiar with the fact that we are turning into a nation with a controlled media. Plenty of news stories don't make it to the biggest news outlets, hosts who interview guests on TV talk shows are on a mission to illegitimately discredit the liberal/Democratic guests, the nationally televised presidential debates are rigged (so that the questions that get asked are stupid and focus on personal trivia about candidates that give people petty reasons to vote against Democrats instead of focusing on policy questions that will inform the public and let them see that voting for Democrats is in their best interest), talk show panels regularly get stacked with conservative guests instead of liberals and Democrats, etc. These are all standard practices of almost every nationally syndicated TV program with some news content (Keith Olbermann, 60 Minutes, and the Comedy Central comedies are the exceptions, but I believe they are all somewhat effected by the problem as well). So the mainstream media has very clearly been blackmailed, intimidated, bought off, or infiltrated (my guess if that there is a lot of conservative infiltration, and that the other factors (especially intimidation) are present to a smaller extent), and in that case it's not unlikely or unreasonable at all to think that The New Yorker printed a racist cover intending to hurt Barack.
Of course, the mainstream media does not report on the fact that its content (especially its news content) is currently right on the brink of the most prejudiced and biased that content can possibly be towards the right-wing point of view without everyone in the public openly realizing that we have a controlled media.
Posted by
Swan
at
2:27 AM
|
This shouldn't have happened
Fire that cartoonist!
http://www.washingtonmonthly.com/archiv … 014079.php
You'll notice that Michelle Obama is depicted with a big Afro, wearing a bandolier of bullets and an assault rifle, camo pants and army boots. The scene is the Oval Office, where a portrait of Osama bin Laden (or some other traditionally-dressed Middle Eastern man) is hanging up, and an American flag is burning in a fire-place.
The cartoonist is claiming that this is an attempt to satire all the racism against Barack amd show it up. I'd say someone should tell this guy that you don't criticize racism by giving it a huge billboard, but I expect he already knows that. What the cover really looks like is the image one would expect to find on a racist t-shirt.
Is it a satire of racism to put a statue of a mamie or whatever on your lawn?
Anyway, the South Park style of satire is far from what The New Yorker usually does with its covers. I don't follow the magazine closely, but I used to subscribe and I've seen it enough to notice the covers are usually much more tame and sedate. There's something not normal about this new cover.
Let's assume it's legitimate satire: Then can we always criticize racism by this method now? Instead of criticizing racism against Obama in particular, can I criticize racism in the society in general by drawing a cartoon of a bunch of tall black guys holding down a white teenaged girl on her bed, with a basketball sitting next to the bed-- the idea being that it's making fun of what racists fantasize if you depict it? Frankly, if people went walking around with the image from the New Yorker cover (or the hypothetical image I described) on a t-shirt, I think people would have very good reason to think it's a racist image and to be angry with the person wearing the shirt. Calling the New Yorker cartoon legit satire of racism is tantamount to saying that a cartoon like the one I described would be legitimate satire of racism.
I just can't see how what was racist speech yesterday is now all of a sudden anti-racist speech just because this guy is claiming it is. I think considering how screwed-up the media has become (Tim Russert eulogized for a week and a half non-stop?! Come on!) we have reason to be concerned about something like this-- not the opposite.
What if The New Yorker did a cover depicting John McCain smiling and wearing a black SS uniform, sitting on top of a pile of corpses of combat-uniformed American soldiers, with a couple of barrels of oil on either side of the pile, and some green dollars sticking out of McCain's pockets? People would have no trouble saying that editorialism / partisanship to that degree is inappropriate for the cover of the magazine.
If this cartoon was legitimate satire it was way too close to the line of what should be considered legitimate satire (especially because of the context of the times and venue for distribution / audience of the magazine cover, and everything).
I'm still disturbed by the fact that if you just look at the magazine cover for what it obviously looks like (w/o anyone's "explanation"), then what it obviously looks like is a smearing, juvenile racist image about our Democratic presidential candidate got put on the cover of a widely distributed, famous magazine that will appear on newstands all over the country for 1 month. No cartoon in that venue and that could effect a presidential election should require an explanation from the cartoonist in order for people to "get it" instead of very possibly taking a racist message away from it.
If just some kid in a high school drew that for, say, an art class project, students and parents would be rightly offended. Or if it just showed up on a billboard, ditto. Some guy makes ridiculous pretensions to high-mindedness and avant garde art, though, and people are ready to let him get away with putting racist caricatures on the cover of a major magazine.
Hopefully this country has not become so weird over the past few years that some person can get away with this racist characterization of Barack Obama just by throwing out a paper-thin excuse.
Posted by
Swan
at
2:12 AM
|
Monday, July 14, 2008
In case you haven't heard
It turns out that the CIA project to research “mind control” you may have heard about isn’t an urban legend, a hoax or a rumor-- they actually did do a lot of work trying to figure out how to control people's minds with drugs. I can't remember where exactly, but I read recently in at least one place (seems like it was more though) "Oh, those silly rumors about the CIA MK ULTRA project, which we all know is just an urban legend..." or some words to that effect. Since I read a lot of political blogs, could be some conservative moron-- who feels it's his mission in life to make every kind of cop, Western empire, unscrupulous person, etc., that ever existed look as good as possible-- was just trying to make people out there think it was a bunch of poop it they ever happen to hear the name of the op in conversation, or glance it in a piece of writing.
You used to (prior to 9/11) hear a lot of nasty things about the CIA. Since 9/11, they've got a considerable whitewashing (by which I mean the media refuses to say a single bad thing about them, except the leaking of some evidence that a couple of people died during interrogations they conducted-- everything else they do is portrayed from a shallow & uncritical "you can see the arguments on both sides" perspective).
But anyway, this old project fits the old image of the CIA you used to hear about (probably more truly reflecting them), that they're a bunch of jerkwad hacks. For MK ULTRA, they secured a bunch of money they had zero accountability for, and they conducted a bunch of totally unscientific field experiments on often unwilling and unknowing subjects, including plenty of American civilians (these were not intelligence targets, just random schmoes the CIA decided to mess around with since they were big and bad CIA agents and the people were just regular old innocent U.S. citizens). The results of their ridiculous caper (besides killing some people and permanently ruining some people’s lives) were finding out the drugs they investigated (mostly LSD) wouldn’t make people controllable the way the CIA was looking for.
There is a bunch of substantiation at the Wikipedia page, including citations to Senate-floor remarks from Sen. Ted Kennedy and a Supreme Court opinion related to the program: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_MKULTRA
Despite the totally legitimate documentation of this, it still seems kept quiet. When was the last time you saw the words "MK ULTRA" in a mainstream source? The documentation is out there, but TV, the newspapers, and Hollywood don't want to talk about it. Which isn't good, since a bunch of idiots shouldn't be, you know, left to their own devices to do things like this to people. Maybe if people had mentioned MK ULTRA a little more during this whole so-called "War on Terror" thing, people would have realized "Oh, these CIA jerks are just a bunch of used-car salesmen and deluded assholes" and wouldn't have depended on praise from President Bush, the fiction TV show 24, and appearances on TV news programming by "ex-"CIA agents for their low-down on the CIA.
If the documentation was well-known, people should have been saying "MK ULTRA" non-stop during all this bidness about the interrogations and Abu Ghraib and whatnot. I assume it is well-known to a few people, but those people don't seem to have done a good job of explaining what it is in newspapers, TV shows, the blogs, etc., besides perhaps just mentioning the name and omitting the important details.
It seems like everyone got so scared after 9/11, even a lot of liberals forgot to mention that the CIA are a bunch of jackoffs and started eating up the line that the CIA are a bunch of expert, nice, bipartisan guys out to help us all. As too often turns out to be the case with intelligence agencies, it seems they've become more like the goons that lawmakers think we can't get rid of, or are too afraid to try. Really, what's your remedy against the CIA? Sub-departments or even the whole agency could be amassing all sorts of power and we wouldn't know it, and maybe the Senate and the President wouldn't even know it. They could be intensely ideological and we wouldn't know it.
Posted by
Swan
at
4:45 AM
|
Sunday, July 13, 2008
Tony Snow no longer working as propagandist-- sounds good to me
And I don't mind much that he died, either.
Should we have expressed sympathy to Goebbels' family when he died? Probably not, right?
What if Goebbels had died just prior to WWII? One year prior? Two years prior?
I think we're better off without Tony Snow, and in light of all that the Bush administration has done to Americans, I think what is impolite is expressing any regret over Snow's death.
That's one less guy who got us into Iraq for Cheney's oil, and then worked to keep us there, without a single sincere regret.
It's not worth mourning the likes of him, not in this day and age and considering what our country has gone through. If his kind had been less successful harming our country, maybe I'd be sucker enough to express some token regret over this guy's death (but even if all the extraordinarily bad things that have happened to our country after 9/11 hadn't happened, Tony Snow would probably just have been sticking up for Republican vote-stealing tactics, or the Rovian slime machine, or something similarly sinister, anyway). I see no reason to kiss the ass of someone who abuses us like this just because he died (a perfectly natural thing that inevitably happens to everybody, good and bad alike).
Good riddance.
Posted by
Swan
at
5:20 PM
|
Civilian Hummers: a very bad historical accident
The funniest thing about this is that a commenter in Matt's comments section suggests that maybe the reason people buy big SUVs is that they think they will be better-protected by them in an accident.
Maybe, and maybe they are safe vehicles (not that I've heard of, though) but if all those people were so interested in safety, why didn't we see a huge trend of people buying little Volvos? Those are the safest cars by a longshot, as far as I've ever heard. Seems to me people who buy SUVs are more like selfish jackass types, and having a big car gives them a power trip-- so it's probably more about hoping you make other drivers on the road feel like the Hummer would do a lot of damage to their cars in a collision, than it is about guaranteeing your life. Why don't all the macho and neanderthal-sized drivers the WaPo writer references duck into safe, fuel-efficient European cars all the time? Probably the look of those cars doesn't aid the self-delusions that they use to make up for their personal failings and deficiencies enough.
Here's what I wrote in Matt's comments:
What is he saying? You need to be a certain height to drive a certain car? Doesn't make sense to me. You'd have to be pretty short to have a lot of trouble stepping into an SUV.
Why doesn't he think the 6' 4" guy is driving it to boost his self-esteem-- like maybe because the 6' 4" guy is stupid and driving a big car is the only way to make himself feel like he's an impressive, successful person?
People as big as Arnold Schwarzenegger seem to be for the most part less smart, and examples who become wildly successful (like Arnold and Jesse Ventura) seem to be the very few exceptions.
Sorry, the Hummer isn't any different a status symbol than any other expensive car-- except that it's a ridiculous waste of money / gas, so that when the decision to buy a status-symbol type car is a bad one for a particular person to make, if it's a Hummer that's bought, it's extra bad.
Posted by
Swan
at
3:57 PM
|
Wednesday, July 2, 2008
Obama Wants To Expand The Peace Corps
Link.
I think Barack is saying a lot of really disappointing things lately, from a liberal point of view. The Peace Corps is a good thing in the abstract in a few ways, but I feel like conservatives like it because it takes liberal young people out of the country (who would otherwise be advocating for liberal politics here in America). It basically decreases our ranks to win political victories and take things away from the Republicans.
Think about the '60s and all the important social movements and legislation that were going on then, or have their origins in 1960s liberal activism. How much of that really would have taken-off if tens of thousands of people who had the guts and compassion it takes to go suffer in a dangerous foreign country for several years in the Peace Corps had joined up with them instead of being student activists on college campuses? (I know the Peace Corps began in the '60, but what if it had been bigger and more successfully recruited volunteers). And how many of the second-stringers as far as personality and intelligence would have made the student organizations and activism in general as successful at college campuses across the country as the most talented student leaders did? Remember, we have to do all this in the face of Republican attempts at disruption and misinformation. We're not served in this endeavor by having any of our best people drop out from participating at least in some capacity to do something else (that takes them entirely away from American political advocacy).
Right now what we most need is to decisively win at politics in America, to defend against the Republicans. We no more need liberal college-age and graduate-school aged people who are brave, motivated and dynamic joining the Peace Corps than we need them going over to fight in Iraq.
Let Europe-- or some other First World nation that isn't struggling with the Bushies, who currently command the world's strongest military and greatest economy-- do what the Peace Corps does. What Barack is suggesting runs counter to what should be basic Democratic strategy right now. You know young Karl Roves, Frank Luntzes and Sean Hannitys aren't going to join the Peace Corps, or at least not in anything like the relative numbers to the whole number of their activists that young liberals will.
The Peace Corps would be good at another time. It would certainly redound to our nation's benefit if we didn't have more pressing needs for their personnel, because it could increase stability in the world. But right now doing better at American domestic politics should be a priority that trumps the Peace Corp's need for volunteers.
Posted by
Swan
at
11:25 AM
|
Tuesday, July 1, 2008
Religious Organizations
Atrios says this: "I don't actually have a problem with money going to church-linked organizations as long as they aren't exempt from oversight or anti-discrimination laws and don't proselytize."
I don't think any public money should go to religious organizations. They already get an exemption from (some?) taxes.
If someone wants to believe in a higher power as a hobby, fine. If they benefit from some of the beliefs or claimed "knowledge" of a religion, fine as well. But religions discourage people from believing in things like science and the moral worth of their neighbors, despite the nicer versions of religions that are out there. We don't need to be funding ideological missions that actually run against the grain of (what should be) our public policy.
We should just feed the poor in another way. They should be helped through government assist / training programs and private funding of religion. Religion shouldn't receive any megaphone from the state, nor should it have any kind of foothold or voice in state functions.
Why can't poor people be given public works jobs that require little or no training (things like cleaning up the streets of trash, erasing the more tasteless pieces of graffiti, and doing the most menial and simple tasks in state-highway construction projects)? People who can't work because of something like mental illness can be given appropriate and meaningful assistance instead-- like new state homes for the mentally ill that are staffed by, say, college students (encouraging work + consumer spending further by creating more new jobs) and that do not degrade them, dissimilar to the old state-run mental institutions that were staffed by screwed-up people and people from bad neighborhoods.
Why should public money be spent to fund groups that create conservative voters and encourage conservative propaganda?
Religions make men more disrespectful of women (and I don't just mean that women should be able to get abortions). Even if liberals were to give up abortion as a concession to the conservatives, having decided that unwanted pregnancies and physical dangers to the mother of pregnancy are no longer what they once were, lots of males from certain religions think it’s their right to push women around and to give them orders. I think human civilizations need leadership and deference (hierarchies) at this point in some form like we have them already, but in this day and age, there are much better bases for leadership and deference than male or female physiology (and everything that goes with them). The idea that men should always control women is a destructive impulse that runs counter to a lot of institutions in our society and would take away a lot of prosperity that has probably been achieved because of increased equality for women. Some conservative religious types would probably say that I have it backwards, and that they respect women more because they oppose things like pornography more than we liberals do, but I'd have to say that they can't read our minds- that is, they don't really know how much looking at pornography has or doesn't have to do with disrespecting or objectifying women in general for every man who looks at it- and that, while some of those criticisms of things like pornography and legalization of prostitution seem to at least have some merit, secularists can adopt those criticisms too. But still, conservative religion's misogyny won't be enough to justify its more pernicious parts that are left-over in the balance (that is to say, even if all liberals and all religious people agreed on something like a ban of pornography, religions would still be misogynistic enough in other beliefs-- beliefs that we liberals don't agree with-- for us to be able to see that giving aid to the religions' promoting their points of view on those issues isn't worth it).
In fact, I think conservative religious people, rather than being so concerned with the wlefare of women, more tend to use their criticisms about pornography as an excuse to bash liberals and/or people who don't believe in religion, when they should actually know better (i.e., it should be plain to them that everyone who isn't in favor of banning pornography doesn't look down on women). So it's not only a flawed argument, it's a specious and dishonest one.
Religions do promote a lot of social training / social functions that I think almost all of us can agree with, like some degree of sexual morality and public-spiritedness or love for our fellow humans. But those kinds of values can be taught (and in a less arbitrary, 4,000-year-old-book-related way) by secular persons and programs. And perhaps people would even become better, more engaged parents (and more moral in general) if they realized they had to think about and focus on teaching their kids the right things to do and the right way to think, and that they can't just drop the kid off at Sunday school or Temple and hope that everything will turn out ok with how the kid sees right and wrong.
All of this is more reason to limit state spending on religion as a general public policy.
Posted by
Swan
at
3:03 PM
|
Monday, March 3, 2008
Defending Women
First things first, I think that something like the piece reported on here is definitely weird, is not normal, and should not be printed in a Western, American, civilized newspaper. I think it's entirely appropriate to write this person or write the paper about it to complain (you'll likely only get some kind of obfuscating, dishonest response, if any, but that's to be expected & besides the point) or even better, to write about it on a blog, e-mail list, or e-mail to friends, or to talk to people about it. The fact that a woman wrote this piece shouldn't deter you-- it's par for the course for the Republicans to give us their most anti-African American, anti-woman, and so on, messages from, respectively, a black person, a woman, or what have you. You shouldn't mistake it at all for not being propaganda for that fact, and I wouldn't be surprised if a man actually helped this woman write this piece, or wrote it for her.
The piece seems to basically be an argument based on the distinction between "intelligent" and "wise" and seems to argue that women are not wise, since the raw-intelligence argument is one that people are less likley to buy. Even worse for a right-wing propagandist, it's very un-PC to try to argue that men have greater raw-intelligence than do women. The reason the writer makes the argument she does is, I think, to get women- one of our core blocs- to feel less confident and to feel less like voting and participating in politics (a lesser goal may have been to make women feel like they should 'get out of the way' of men). I'm sure plenty of people, once they get around some emotional responses, will be able to respond to this just as adequately as I can, but because I know some people will be emotional about this and will let this piece mess with their minds (indeed, it wouldn't have been written if the writers didn't feel confident it would have this effect on some people) I am going to make sure a refutation-- mine-- gets out there, so people will be less likely to be bowled over by a psychological assault like this piece.
I have aggravating relationships and interactions with all kinds of people, and I meet all kinds of people that I think have poor characters (as do probably most of us). But this piece is chauvinistic, and tries to lump it all on women. The first thing that needs to be said is, despite this piece's focus on women being frivolous and shallow, men themselves are often frivolous and shallow- women may, to excess, want to hang out in Bed, Bath & Beyond and then gobble some candy or goodies on the way home (while growing fat); men-- to excess-- watch stupid football games, talk about football, and chew tobaccco, smoke cigars, eat red meat or sodium-laden nuts and chips and so on (while growiong fat). It's not for me to say which sex spends the absolute most time on shallow stuff. But if we're going to judge only based on our anecdotal experience, like this and so many other stupid writers do, it's very easy to come to a tit-for-tat, between men and women, description of what is going on.
Second, the piece seems between-the-lines to be trying to apologize for men who are sort of busted and crummy-- guys who can't commiserate or empathize with a person emotionally and who view the world in a fucked-up and simplistic way. I got the sense the writer was saying, "You stupid women don't listen to dumb, asshole militaristic right-wing men who really know what's best for our country because you stupidly, mistakenly, prefer to listen to people who have all the flair." I think what's really happening is that women tend to listen to people who seem smarter and who seem to care about them more. They're turned off by people who are more anti-social, who function less well in a group, and who seem sadistic and preoccupied with hurting things and people. A focus on things like that- on valuing the opinions of people who are smart and who seem to care about people more- is the kind of thing that women have perennially, and very fortunately for society, contributed a great deal to providing. This in turn has helped to provide a balance against all the dumb assholes a society produces. Sure, some people may mistake false sentiments or concern for the real stuff sometimes, as does everybody. And probably, women are more concerned with closeness and relationships than men are, and there is a lot of science demonstrating a physical/biological and psychological basis for this. What I don't get out of this piece is why that's wrong. Sure, if that was only what people cared about, and couldn't see when it was time to make some hard decisions because they were always blinded by the possibility that every asshole might turn out to be a nice guy, that would be a terrible thing; but that hardly seems to be the case, based on my experience of the women I've known (women are plenty good at being practical), plus, there is an absolute and crucial value in valuing other people very much, even to the point of being sentimental about it. In fact, that sentimentality and esteem for others is so pervasive, it's an easy conclusion to draw to say that our society would probably be destroyed without it.
The writer doesn't seem to stand in absolute opposition to this. Her last (horrible) sentence is:
...I don’t understand why more women don’t relax, enjoy the innate abilities most of us possess (as well as the ones fewer of us possess) and revel in the things most important to life at which nearly all of us excel: tenderness toward children and men and the weak and the ability to make a house a home.... Then we could shriek and swoon and gossip and read chick lit to our hearts’ content and not mind the fact that way down deep, we are . . . kind of dim.So, despite her criticism of (what she apparently sees as) the horror of chick lit and Celine Dion, she ultimately doesn't seem to be calling for an end to that, just for people to either feel kind of bad about their liking chick-culture-stuff, or to feel that it's a reason for them to back out of men's way, and let other people think about weightier things, like politics.
To go back to my original point, this is just like saying that men shouldn't think about politics, because some of them are so distracted by something absolutely frivolous and unimportant- men chasing balls on football fields- that if they have the poor judgment to waste so much time that way, they also must have such poor judgment generally, as a sex, that they shouldn't make decisions with regard to anything important.
The writer's remarks are so chauvinistic and mistaken that they are an affront to women everywhere in our culture, and, worse than that, if taken seriously they will mislead us into behaving in ways that will hurt our culture.
Posted by
Swan
at
8:34 AM
|
Friday, February 29, 2008
I Told Ya So
Via CB:
The Dems’ Texas primary on Tuesday is open to independents and Republicans, and they may give Obama an edge: “If the latest polling data are to be believed, those Republicans aren’t whispering in Texas, where 195 of the 228 delegates the state will send to the Democratic National Convention will be chosen in a primary and caucuses Tuesday. As many as a tenth of the Texans voting in the Democratic contests could be Republicans, and overwhelmingly they favor Obama, a first-term senator from Illinois, the polls show.”I've been posting comments to a few different sites for a while now suggesting that the unusual youth turnout for Obama in Iowa, the unusually strong turnouts in our primaries and caucuses in general, and the big leads Obama has been getting have been partly due to Republican raiding, or switching parties in a primary to vote for who they believe is the weaker of the opposition's two candidates. I hope for some people this will be more believable now that they are presented with this evidence standing right in front of their faces.
There are a few reasons why I think the Republicans would want us to run Obama. One is that, I think they think Obama is going to end up being easier to beat. If there's a whisper-campaign to get Republicans to raid for Obama, it may also be part of it to get them to respond to polls about the general election saying that they are Democrats and are going to vote for Obama, so pollsters might not necessarily reveal the raiding. They may think he is easier to beat because they may think that voters are still too racist to vote for him when it comes down to the day of the general election- even if they think the polls show him as strong, they may be relying on a Bradley Effect, and on Republican gap-closing propaganda to work especially well on a black man with Obama's foreign, Muslim-sounding name. Also I think they may think Hillary is more wise to Republican trickery and dastardly political maneuvers than is Obama. Finally, I think for some core Republicans, misogyny may just be stronger than racism when picking a Commander in Chief.
If this last reason is really the biggest reason why the Republicans are favoring Obama, then we have the least to worry about if the Republicans really have monkey-wrenched our primary election process and got us to favor a candidate who, for all his public speaking aptitude, is really the less-electable and less smart candidate. If however the other two reasons represent better what's going on, than if the Republicans have cause us to nominate Obama instead of Hillary, we have steered ourselves into something of a jam.
Posted by
Swan
at
12:28 PM
|