On July 24, 1997, William J. Brennan, Jr., a liberal U.S. Supreme Court Justice, died in Washington, DC. A Newark, New Jersey native, Brennan's father had been active in the organized labor movement, and before becoming a Justice, Brennan was a lawyer for organized labor. Brennan served on the 1960s' liberal Warren court alongside Justice Marshall, the first African American Justice on the Supreme Court, a former NAACP lawyer, and also a staunch liberal. Brennan then served on the increasingly conservative Burger and Rehnquist courts, during which he valiantly represented the liberal position in dissenting opinions for many years. These dissenting opinions could help pave the way for judicial approaches to individual rights in the state courts, to govern individual rights matters in which state constitutions are allowed to give better protection against the actions of a state government than federal law requires. Brennan served as a Justice for about 34 years, from October 16, 1956 – July 20, 1990, and died at the age of 91.
Thursday, July 24, 2008
The McCain Poster
Everyone's taking turns making fun of McCain's new poster, so I think I should report what I think. I think this is an example of a time when I have to choose not to be "on message" for us and say something that's calculated to whip people up to go out to vote against the Republicans, and instead play devil's advocate a little- mostly I want to do this to help people develop what I think is better judgment on things, like how to play politics better. And that's why I have to say I think the poster is not that bad. Here are comments I wrote on two other blogs (slightly edited to make them better here):
I don't think the poster is that bad for them-- its message just seems to be "Our guy knows that we have to fight to achieve peace in the long-run, and the liberals aren't willing to do that." It keeps them well-settled in their over-all frames/message, makes John McCain sound less like a war-monger without putting him in a position of having to say or promise something he's not going to actually follow up on (i.e., any kind of genuine peacenik moves like getting us out of Iraq or not leaving permanent bases), and it keeps the actual debating (but not the advertisements) in the campaign focused on things like whether or not we need to be fighting now, whether the fights the Republicans will start will make us safer, etc., instead of on some kind of precarious ideological battle between whether you like the idea of us being in wars or whether you put a premium on peace when we can have it (the poster just chooses peace, genuinely or not, as the lowest common denominator and therefore the appeal to be made). So when it comes to debates and printed material, McCain and his campaign will be free to make arguments based on uncertain, unknowable future events, and facts the average voter is ignorant about (nitty-gritty historical details and facts about Iraq policy and military policy)-- comfortable stuff for a politician trying to get elected.* * *
The poster doesn't even have any offensive content, which is less and less common for the Republicans when they open their mouths nowadays.
I really think the poster is fine. It's his arguments about when we should be at peace and when we should be at war I feel like challenging, not this facially benign poster. Aesthetically, it's a little too lush for what I would want, but as Kevin points out, that's probably because the poster is designed to most directly target a demographic that grew up when posters in this style were more with-it.
You can't even really call the poster corny on its own terms, I think (that is, without consideration of the fact that McCain the man is about as heroic and noble and wise as the Sheriff of Nottingham, and therefore the poster-- for portraying him as if he were otherwise-- is absurd). But as just a poster of a guy who is running for President, it seems like a perfectly fine poster to me- if you put Hillary or Edwards or Barack on it, but kept it the same otherwise, I don't see what the problem would be.
Posted by
Swan
at
3:21 AM
|
Wednesday, July 23, 2008
We are not Iraq's nursemaids
I saw this comment from a conservative on a blog today, My question is, what is now best for the Iraqi people, and I like my response so much, I decided to post it as a blog-post here:
We should help people when we can, but that does not mean that we have to try to help people we can't actually help.What we should do is prevent Iraq from descending into anarchy if we can and if it's worth the price. We can do that if all it takes is sending out some forces to kick the butts of gangs that get too violent and militant. But if the whole country wants to kill each other, then what it takes at the least to prevent anarchy is to occupy the whole country. If you look at it in terms of what all the money and manpower could be doing elsewhere, it's not worth the cost. That may sound hard at first, but it's not-- it's really benevolent towards people we could be doing a much better job of helping, but we're not since the conservatives are pulling (almost) all the strings, and it's benevolent to all the U.S. troops who are going to get hurt and killed in Iraq, and it's benevolent to those troops' families.
We've got no more a moral obligation to fix Iraq than we do to transform the Moon or Mars into habitable environments for future generations to escape to if earth gets too messed up- it's too big a task. There are other people we can help a lot more and a lot more easily (like people in America, or people abroad who are impoverished but live in less violent areas than Iraq) and if we were truly acting humanistically, those are the peole we would be helping, not squandering lives and resources in Iraq.
Iraq might benefit from a far more limited presence (that is dedicated solely to getting bad guys when they get violent) but our massive presence there is perhaps even provoking more violence than it is preventing. In any event, even if our presence makes some areas of their country safer, it is a real waste (in terms of how much good it does and how lasting that good is likely to be) compared to the good the money and manpower could be doing somewhere else.
Posted by
Swan
at
4:05 PM
|
Al-Maliki, Conservatives, and the Iraq War
UPDATE: One thing that makes me think the conservatives (at a high level of leadership) want to get out of the Iraq war is that current and former military commanders have been admitting (and the news has been getting out that they have been admitting) that they want to get out of the Iraq war, and on to Afghanistan, or that they think the Iraq war is a bust.
If you check out this story, you'll discover the White House was sending out an e-mail to its rank-and-file supporters (ordinary people who signed up to their mailing list) stating that Iraq's Prime Minister Nouri Al-Maliki favors Barack Obama's withdrawal plan and wants our military forces to leave Iraq. The more I've thought about this, the more I've come to believe that this was really unlikely a blunder, and to believe that it was done intentionally. I'm now convinced that something you may have seen me speculate on-- that the Republicans could have changed their position on Iraq (on whether the occupation can work out or not-- whether things can change lastingly for the better) sometime over the last year or so, and are just now more and more taking actions to dissolve the political support for occupation among their base (by doing things like advertising the fact that the Iraqis want us to leave) so that the environment will be made comfortable for the leading Republican voices to openly change their minds about it and the policy to be changed. It's very tiresome, even revolting, when the Republicans have up til this point pretended that staying in was the only possible answer and the idea of leaving was close to treasonous. So it makes sense that they would pull this cowardly move, and try to obliquely convince all their friends we should leave before they openly say we should leave. It's a hard "We were wrong" to state to the parents, friends and relatives of all those troops who got hurt and died-- people who the Republicans swore up and down to that we absolutely needed to be in Iraq, and that the liberals were all being a bunch of idiots for saying we shouldn't be.
Something that convinced me more of this was the fact that I'd already concluded that Al-Maliki was a conservative stooge, but he was starting to say that we should leave. It could look out of place at first- why would a conservative stooge say he wanted us to leave if the conservatives wanted us to stay, like they kept saying? But that reminded me of other things I'd seen earlier that make me suspicious that the conservatives at many levels of personnel were becoming very doubtful of the Iraq war, which indeed was not improving (couldn't they see it?). If I had been right about the conservatives changing course on the Iraq war, it would make sense that Al-Maliki would say that we should get out if he was a conservative stooge, because it gives the conservatives the perfect, face-saving excuse to get out: the Iraqis don't want us there, and even the leader of the country is saying it.
It's a similar observation to mine about the global warming debate- conservative/fundamentalist TV pastors, who go up on the soap-box for conservative politics all the time, were suddenly changing "their" positions on global warming. If it really was so clear that global warming was a real problem by this point, wouldn't responsible conservatives come around eventually and want to take that position back? And wouldn't the most obvious, most two-faced shills for the conservatives have a hand in clearing the way for that? I wouldn't necessarily say that every conservative preacher who has been in the news for publicly changing his stance on global warming has to be doing so at the behest of a conservative, political master. But I expect that at least one or some were.
On Monday, the Carpetbagger Report blog featured this sentence:
The right now has a new idea on how to deal with the debate over Iraq policy: go after Maliki as an Iranian stooge. Didn’t conservatives love this guy as recently as last week?But they linked it up to this link. If you go and follow the link, it's to an article about just one guy (and no one particularly famous) calling Maliki an Iranian stooge. So it's not even some new conservative policy to do this-- rather it's just one guy (who presumably can't by-himself counteract weeks and months of conservative messaging about how they love Maliki).
So that sounds a lot more like a red herring thrown to liberals to throw them off the course of realizing Maliki is a conservative stooge than it sounds like a piece of evidence that contradicts my theory.
This theory still makes sense if the guys who want to change the conservative stance on the Iraq war can't bring McCain into the fold, because he is headstrong and dumb. If that's the case, then they may feel the need to change the rank-and-file conservatives first, so Weathervane John can discern the need to change his position. Or, he may already be in on it, but is just waiting for the voters to change their minds on Iraq before he publicly changes his position.
Posted by
Swan
at
10:54 AM
|
July 23
On this date in 1944, Soviet forces made the first liberation of a Holocaust concentration camp (Majdanek). The Soviets would go on to make the second liberation (of Auschwitz, the most notorious camp) as well sometime later, and other camps were liberated after that by other Allied forces. The last two camps to be dissolved were actually destroyed by the Nazis, not liberated by Allied forces, close to the Nazis' surrender.
Posted by
Swan
at
10:11 AM
|
Obama, Clinton, and the Public
It's funny that people bought up this whole media line (not to mention, Obama campaign line) than Barack is so different from the Clintons and "politics as usual." Barack talks about change over and over again, and people eat it up, but wasn't Bill elected in his first term on promises of change and not playing the old political game in the same old way?
I feel like even discerning people preferred him over Hillary based mostly just on this talking point. But that was the same exact thing Bill Clinton was saying 16 years ago. So how is that different?
Posted by
Swan
at
10:06 AM
|
Sunday, July 20, 2008
Clinton Won't Be Veep
This sounds like something I was thinking today.
I guess it's safe to bet by now that Clinton won't be picked by Obama to be his Veep. If he wanted to do it, there is no reason why he wouldn't have done it promptly (i.e., by now), since she's such an obvious choice, and has so many supporters. Hillary and her husband probably are starting to realize this and to feel burned, since it probably seemed like she was a pretty logical choice for Barack, and it probably seemed not a bad bet that he would pick her-- so, they might have been inclined to just keep assuming it would likely-as-not happen, even though a formal decision / announcement might take a long time for whatever reasons (like Barack wanting to appear like he was making a considered decision, and not reflexively bowing to so-called "powerful" or "obvious" choices).
Some people might challenge my premise that Hillary is such an obvious choice. They may look at what the media has to say about it, and contend that because the media says so, that there are actually a lot of reasons not to want Hillary. But I would answer that that is what the media says-- the Republican, taken-over, media. In fact, Hillary Clinton is a great choice, and brings a lot of loyal followers, fund-raising potential and wonky, public-spirited experience to the fold. People may say that Barack wouldn't want to be smothered or out-shone by Hillary-- that the town isn't big enough for the both of them. But Barack has already beaten Hillary in the battle for the nomination, and people already commonly acknowledge that he is a better speaker than her (another piece of evidence about this is the fact that his speaking events have always attracted a much larger number of attendees than hers). How is she going to outshine him? And Bill Clinton is a disgraced, tired old man. Instead of worrying he could be outshone by them, Barack could be getting a power-trip off of outshining the Clintons himself.
Other people may say that a rejection of Hillary is a rejection of "the system" or "the way things are done in Washington." But Hillary was never that "plugged in" or powerful. Those were things just what the Republicans tried to demonize her as. Hillary and Bill were pro-black, pro-working class upstarts. The media is not nearly as hard on George W. Bush, one of the worst and dumbest Presidents in U.S. history, as it has been on Hillary. And someone who is truly "plugged in" and "powerful" in more than a transitory sense does not get regularly ridiculed by a corrupt news media, and does not have her innocent daughter preyed on by them, and does not have them and the government work as hard as possible through very corrupt means to expose her husband's affair. No, Hillary Clinton is not American royalty, and she is not anything like it.
In turn, Barack's refusal to make the easy choice of picking Hillary to be veep is further evidence for my theory that he has been compromised (bullied or threatened by Republicans into following their orders), which I now feel pretty convinced of. Hillary and Bill seem to be out-of-the-loop of the VP selection process, too-- so if Barack was for real on this, why would he keep stringing them and Hillary supporters along for so long? Why wouldn't he be a little more overtly definite about what he's doing? Probably whoever he picks out to be his veep will be someone who secretly harbors Republican loyalties.
Posted by
Swan
at
8:15 PM
|
Global Warming
Here's something weird I noticed a little while ago:
I was out at my local supermarket and noticed Complete Idiot's Guide to Global Warming on the magazine rack by the checkout. It wasn't a single copy-- not a random copy that had been left there from another part of the store-- but a bunch of copies, set up for sale at a number of the checkout lines.
This was weird for two reasons:
(1) They don't usually sell Complete Idiot's guides in the magazine racks of the checkouts in that grocery store, on in any grocery store I go to
(2) Although there may be a bigger, book-bound edition of Complete Idiot's Guide to Global Warming, this was a little pamphlet-bound book, like a Reader's Digest.
Conclusion: I think it's propaganda. I didn't check it out to see which side it was propaganda for, for I can't say for sure. But my guess would be that it's written to convince people that global warming is real. Global warming and the Iraq war are two things I think the conservatives have, at a high level of leadership, decided to reverse course about, but are not coming out overtly about the change yet (it's a hard change to overtly make- they've been pushing so hard in the other direction for so long, so they have to be changing their minds out of a belief in the absolute necessity of it- for poor personalities like the Republicans', just biting the bullet and changing their stance in the most definite and assertive way possible must be very tough). The conservatives just want liberals and cities to be the ones to start agitating for work on global warming first, and to adopt trends of using reusable shopping bags at food stores first, so red state hicks can play the role of not being the type who are overly concerned about things like that, but more concerned with competitive sports and being tough-looking SUV drivers.
Circumstantial evidence of this is the fact that conservative pastors / ministers (shameless hacks who work as conservative propaganda pieces, rather than sincerely being concerned with religion, just as much as journalists do) have changed their tune on global warming recently, deciding that their God-given expertise on global warming now requires them to proselytize from the pulpit in the other direction about that issue.
Since all mass-marketed media in America (not just TV news and newspapers, but book publishers) seem to be heavily infiltrated by conservative activists and propagandists, it seems possible that this could be what happened. The biggest shame is that we don't get more done on our own to agitate for change on emissions standards, etc., until the situation is so far gone that the Republicans (i.e., the dumb people) realize that it's a necessity to change our country's practices.
In sum, the pamphlet is the latest evidence that the Republicans are working to undermine the results they already obtained by way of their own misinformation campaign.
Posted by
Swan
at
11:16 AM
|
Friday, July 18, 2008
The Stalins And Maos Are The Republicans
Kevin Drums excerpts some words of stupidity from David Brooks, and I respond:
Brooks is probably just trying to get people scared that if it's the Democrats who are responsible for all this broad legislation, they are going to end up implementing some kind of ridiculous, socialist authoritarian command-economy bullshit.
People don't need to worry- that's not how policy is made in America at the federal level nowadays (at least, it's not how Democrats make honest efforts to solve real problems). Instead, federal law-makers can get help from all kinds of think tanks, experts, and academics who can make specific policy suggestions or who can even be retained in teams to study a problem for months and years and come up with the whole diagnosis of a problem and comprehensive suggestions for legislation themselves. It isn't like a bunch of idiots fiddling around with trying to control everything about the country.
If conservatives and underinformed types want to vex about what wen wrong in the Soviet Union, they shold consider that the Soviet Union's leaders were a bunch of idiots, bullies, and bumpkins, a lot more like putting Bush, Rove, and the like in charge of a command economy than like putting modern democrats and the academics they form policy with in absolute control of a nation. The USSR was a bunch of hostile, amateurish people trying to make decisions they weren't qualified to make, but got to make because they were politically loyal. That's 8- or 9/10 of why their country failed so badly, not their communal ideology. The Republicans are trying to do the same thing- award decision-making authority based on political loyalty, not professional qualification. In countries like the USSR, it was the scum and the bullies who rose to the top in everything, not the smart people- the only difference between the USSR then and the USA today being, now it's the scum and the bullies who are rising to the top of a capitalist, not a command, system.
A better analog to look to to see who is more like the communist leaders, Republicans or Democrats, is Iraq. Iraq is a place where the Republicans have had a chance to rebuild a country almost from the ground-up. Even not counting the problems related to violence there, the Republicans have failed miserably (and done a USSR-worthy job). Same with the Katrina rebuilding.
In many ways, too, the Republicans are making our country more and more like a command system all the time, which (at least with this kind of leaders) will produce results more and more like the USSR did over time.
UPDATE: If you want to know the reasons the USSR failed, these are them (and these aren't some kind of subtle, esoteric reasons that somehow caused a gigantic failure of a huge nation, and that you need some kind of special degree to be able to discern; rather all it takes is some knowledge):
1) The USSR was a country that underwent generations' worth of ideological purges (people being sent away from the regular economy and community to slave-labor camps or political prisons, often for political reasons, but most definitely often only on political pretenses but in actuality for arbitrary reasons- like personal dislike, or they stodd in the way of an official's ambitions) of thousands at a time. This means that lots and lots of people who thought for themselves, were capable, and just weren't powerful, selfish or savvy enough to protect themselves from the KGB and the like were basically done away with-- or, they were smart enough to successfully flee these dangers for the west. This is why Russia today is a cesspool of crime where 13 year old girls whore themselves on the streets on Moscow. Smart and capable people do things like discover technologies, solve problems, start cool projects and initiatives, and make things nice. When you take them away, the people you have left by themselves (the ones who can't read) pick up guns and start shooting each other in the head. The easiest modern example of this is Iraq. All the worthwhile people high-tailed it out of there or were assassinated. This is not to say Russia lost all its good, smart people. But the ones who were leftover were far more likely to be less-smart nerds (and therefore less offending, or less capable of fleeing) or evil nerds (less ideologically rebellious, but also less public-spirited in actuality, and therefore poorer contributors to the community).
(2) A somewhat-relate point to the first one: The procedures and norms governing advancement in various party/state organization in the USSR were such that people were able to advance in their jobs more easily by attacking their peers instead of by doing their jobs well.
(3) The USSR was oppressive (and this ruined people's morale as workers and turned them, at least in some respects, against their nation and countrymen).
(4) Oppression motivated capable and intelligent people to flee the USSR just like the ideological purges did.
(5) A command economy does not meet consumer demand as effectively and efficiently as does a limited capitalist economy.
(6) A command economy does not provide as much of a spur to innovation in technology (nor to other kinds of achievement) as does a limited capitalist economy.
(7) Organized labor was not really powerful in the Soviet Union as it was in the Soviets’ promises to their people and to the world; it was more rhetoric than reality. The democratic balance organized labor could have played to the state and communist party leadership organizations did not really exist.
(8) The rest of the world was not so interested in spending money on going to the USSR as tourists, perhaps partly because of Soviet rule. Also, there was no hugely popular USSR-export, like something on the scale of Hollywood movies.
(9) The USSR faced opposition from the West. This is the usual hard-lefty's excuse for why many things suck / sucked in the communist nations, but it's just not a realistic explanation by itself for all the problems those countries had.
The conservatives usually focus on (3) and (4) and talk as if these were the only reasons communism failed (they might throw in (2) to give themselves some credibility in a liberal's eyes, but they really do not refer to it to much, and the reason is that they are not per se against oppression, and would like to do it to the extent they can get away with it themselves) however, as you can see, there are plenty of other reasons why that nation came apart.
Posted by
Swan
at
7:36 PM
|
Tuesday, July 15, 2008
An inspiring story
The following is an excerpt from an interesting book I am reading, Stasi, by John O. Koehler, about how the communist government of East Germany politically-policed and otherwise oppressed the people of that country.
As you read it, please keep in mind that the people of these Eastern Block communist countries knew that their political beliefs were being strictly monitored and controlled by the communist governments that were then in power, that they were constantly spied on by secret police forces and by their own neighbors, friends, and relatives, and that they were often spirited away to be interrogated (and ultimately even to be sent to hard-labor camps and prisons) on the merest suspicion of being critical of the government or desiring to flee the country (also the people of these countries were oppressed in many other ways):
[O]n May 5, [1953,] the SED [the communist organization that then ruled East Germany] celebrated the 135th anniversary of the birth of Karl Marx by increasing work quotas for industrial plants. The city of Chemnitz was renamed Karl-Marx-Stadt and the Order of Karl Marx was created as [East Germany’s] highest award. The party seemed to be enjoying a period of unity and political tranquility. It lasted [only two weeks]. Mielke [a high-ranking leader of the Stasi-- East Germany’s Gestapo-like secret political police force] had been reporting secretly that a group of [communist] party officials were plotting against the leadership. This resulted in more expulsions from [high-ranking leadership organizations].The edits in brackets were made by me primarily because the author used a little too much scholarly-sounding language for the passage to be easy for most people to read as an excerpt.
Discontent among the [industrial] workers over increased work norms without corresponding wage hikes reached the breaking point June 16, 1953, at Stalinallee in Berlin. Probably encouraged by Stalin’s death [a few months earlier], nearly a hundred workers gathered for a protest meeting before starting work. Word spread rapidly to other nearby construction sites, and soon several hundred men and women marched to the House of Ministries, the government [building] that once housed Hermann Göring’s Nazi aviation [department]. They chanted in protest for five hours until [an official] decided to speak to them. His cajoling was met with jeers, and he retreated into the heavily guarded building. People’s police riot units were called out of their barracks but made no move to break up the demonstrations. The protesters returned to Stalinallee, and a general strike [that is, a strike of all workers no matter what industry they belonged to] was called. the following day, some 100,000 protesters marched through East Berlin; about 400,000 took to the streets in other towns. Their demands were everywhere the same: free and secret elections.
The American radio station in West Berlin (RIAS) and several West German stations reported the protest marches and the plans for a general strike. These broadcasts were picked up throughout the Soviet zone, and 267,000 workers of major state-owned plants in 304 cities and towns spontaneously went on strike. In 24 towns, [enraged townspeople] stormed prisons and freed between 2,000 and 3,000 inmates [the communist governments imprisoned a lot of people for alleged political disloyalty, so perhaps these townspeople were trying to free friends and relatives they felt were basically kidnapped, rather than just trying to free ordinary criminals].
Mielke was nowhere to be seen in public, but his secret police agents and the Vopo [another communist police force in East Germany] were out en masse, and bloody street battles erupted. Hundreds of policemen defected to the side of the workers, police stations were overrun, and government offices were sacked. The leadership had already retreated to its residences in the heavily guarded compound in the Pankow district of East Berlin. At 1 P.M. the Soviet commandant for Berlin, Major P. K. Dibrova, a sixty-year-old [secret political policeman] who had never seen wartime combat, declared martial law. Stasi agents and people’s policemen opened fire. Drumhead courts handed down death sentences that were carried out on the spot. The rioting continued, and by late afternoon Soviet tanks accompanied by infantry and MVD troops had rolled into East Berlin and other major cities in the Soviet zone. This made the people even angrier. At Berlin’s Potsdamer Platz, which bordered the American sector, [angry] protesters ignored machine gun fire and the menacing barrels of tank guns. They ripped cobblestones from the streets and hurled them at the tanks.
The [] use of Soviet power—two armored divisions—against the protesters in 121 major cities and small towns broke the back of the revolt within twenty-four hours. By nightfall June 18, relative calm had been restored in the Soviet zone, and Stasi flying squads swept through the cities. Provisional prison camps were set up to hold the thousands of Stasi victims. Nearly 1,500 persons were sentenced in secret trials to long prison terms.
On June 24, Mielke issued a terse announcement that one Stasi officer, nineteen demonstrators, and two bystanders had been killed during the uprising. He did not say how many were victims of official lynching. The numbers of wounded were given as 191 policemen, 126 demonstrators, and 61 bystanders. [But it is conceivable that the officially-released number of dead and wounded inflated the numbers of killed and wounded bystanders and demonstrators, and under-reported the numbers of killed and wounded Stasi agents and police officers in order to persuade the demonstrators to believe they had not accomplished much damage by their uprising.]”
This passage is very inspiring to me (as I hope it is to all of you) especially as to what kind of courage people can show and what people can accomplish even when very elaborate and far-reaching methods have been employed to control their opinions and behavior. When people have learned the lessons of people-power, it is very hard for any kind of fascists- even those disguised as populists- to totally oppress the people without more or less having a rough ride of it. And we don’t have to wait for people to set up camps to house political prisoners or to make thinking for yourself a crime in order to start exercising our people-power and to show that we want real freedom, and not just an impostor of it, in this country. It doesn’t take tearing up paving-stones and demonstrating in the street to do it, although I’d say those are definitely the right things to do in certain situations. There is an infinite array of actions that can effectively fight the kind of oppression we don’t want to see in our country and must always be on guard against.
Solidarity!
Posted by
Swan
at
9:26 PM
|